Skip to content
+1 866-872-0096 +1 (250) 860-0096
Selling TipsNovember 18, 20267 minute read

How to Tell If a Gold Buyer in Kelowna Is Giving You a Fair Price

Most sellers only do this once or twice. These are the signs of a fair gold offer, so you can check any buyer's figure, ours included, before you accept it.

Most people sell gold once or twice in their lives, which puts them at a disadvantage against a buyer who does it every day. The good news is that a fair offer is easy to recognise once you know what to watch for. These are the signs we think every seller in Kelowna should look for, whoever they end up selling to.

The buyer shows you the market price they are using

Gold and silver trade globally, and the price moves every day. A fair offer starts from a figure you can see. If a buyer will not tell you what market price they are working from, you have no way to check the rest of the calculation. We show you the figure before we give you a number, and our article on how much your gold is worth in Kelowna walks through the arithmetic with a worked example.

The spot price you find online is for one troy ounce of pure gold, and a troy ounce is 31.1 grams. Gold is priced internationally in US dollars, so a weaker Canadian dollar raises the local price even when the world price has not moved. That is also why a quote from three weeks ago is not a quote today.

The offer is built from three numbers

Every honest scrap gold offer comes from the same three inputs: the market price on the day, the purity of each piece in karats, and the weight in grams of each purity group. Purity multiplied by weight gives the amount of pure gold in front of you, and pricing that against the market gives the gross metal value. What any buyer offers is a share of that figure. If a buyer introduces a fourth input, ask what it is.

No buyer pays a member of the public the full spot price for jewellery. A 14k chain is 58.5 percent gold and the rest is other metals, refining has a real cost, and the buyer carries the market risk until the metal is used. How large a share you receive depends on how many businesses stand between you and whoever actually uses the gold. We manufacture jewellery ourselves, so the gold we buy goes into pieces we make rather than through a chain of resellers.

Your pieces are weighed where you can see the scale

Weight is the biggest number in the calculation, so it should never be measured out of sight. Look for a calibrated scale facing you, with each group weighed separately, in grams. At our counter, nothing leaves your sight at any point.

Testing happens in front of you

A stamp is a claim, not proof. Unmarked and worn pieces should be tested at the counter, electronically or with acid on a touchstone, and you should be told the result. If a piece turns out to be plated rather than solid, a fair buyer tells you and hands it back. Our guide to what your karat stamps actually mean covers the detail.

Marks such as GP, GF, HGE and RGP can look like gold marks, but they identify plated or filled pieces. Where a piece might be plated, a small file mark on an inconspicuous edge shows whether the gold goes all the way through. A fair buyer asks before doing that, every time.

Gold is sorted by karat, not lumped together

Karat is a fraction out of 24. 24k is 99.9 percent gold, 22k is 91.7 percent, 18k is 75 percent, 14k is 58.5 percent, and 10k is 41.7 percent, the lowest that can legally be called gold in Canada. European stamps say the same thing in parts per thousand, so 750 is 18k, 585 is 14k and 417 is 10k.

Those differences are large. An 18k ring is worth roughly 28 percent more per gram than a 14k ring of the same weight. Weighing everything together at a single rate hides that difference, so ask for each karat to be weighed and priced as its own group.

How to compare two quotes fairly

Two totals on their own tell you very little. Ask each buyer for the weight and karat of each group and the market price they used. With those figures you can see whether a difference comes from the price, the weights, the purity reading, or the share of metal value being offered.

Here is how the arithmetic works, using a round figure of $100 per gram of pure gold purely for illustration. The real price on the day will be different. Say you bring 16 grams of 14k and a 6 gram 18k pendant. The 14k group holds 16 x 0.585 = 9.36 grams of pure gold, and the pendant holds 6 x 0.75 = 4.5 grams. Together that is 13.86 grams, a gross metal value of $1,386, and every offer is a share of that figure. If a second buyer records fewer grams or a lower karat for the same group, the per-group figures show it straight away.

Stones and metal are quoted separately

A diamond ring is two things: the stone and the setting. A fair buyer grades the stone on the four Cs where you can see it, quotes the stone and the metal separately, and tells you whether the stone is natural or laboratory-grown. More on selling diamonds in Kelowna.

You are told when something is worth more than its metal

Some coins have collector value above their metal content, and a maker's mark on an antique or designer piece occasionally means it is worth more intact than melted. A buyer who points that out, rather than melting it past you, is a buyer worth dealing with. See selling gold coins and bullion in Kelowna.

An estimate is not dressed up as an appraisal

A cash estimate and a certified appraisal are different things. An appraisal is a formal written valuation, usually at replacement value, for insurance, estate or legal purposes, and it will be higher than any cash offer. We do not do certified appraisals because we are buyers, and we refer people who need one to Stellar Gem Services, an independent jewellery appraiser and certified gem lab in the Okanagan.

Red flags at the counter

  • The scale is turned away from you, or your pieces are taken out of sight to be tested or weighed.
  • No market price is mentioned, or the buyer will not say which one they are using.
  • One number for a mixed pile of different karats.
  • Pressure to accept on the spot instead of leaving with the figure.
  • No request for photo ID.

Questions worth asking any buyer

  • What market price are you using today?
  • What karat did each group test at, and what does each group weigh?
  • Is anything plated, and can you show me why?
  • Is this a buying estimate or an appraisal?
  • Can I take this figure away and decide later?

The buyer is licensed and asks for your ID

Being asked for government-issued photo ID is a good sign, not an inconvenience. Licensed buyers record every purchase against ID, which keeps stolen goods out of the market and protects honest sellers. Bring your driver's licence or passport.

There is no pressure, and a second opinion is welcome

A fair figure survives comparison. You should be able to leave with the number and decide later. Bring any written quote you have already been given, because we guarantee to match or beat any quote in Kelowna and the Okanagan Valley, so getting a second opinion costs you nothing. If you have a mix of gold, diamonds, watches and coins, our page on selling estate jewellery in Kelowna explains how a whole collection is assessed in one visit.

Where to start

We are at Unit 301, 478 Bernard Avenue, ScotiaBank Building, third floor, in downtown Kelowna, open Monday to Sunday, 9 AM to 5 PM. Call +1 866-872-0096 toll free, or +1 (250) 860-0096 locally. The estimate takes about fifteen minutes, is free and carries no obligation, and our free gold estimates in Kelowna page explains how the visit runs.

Frequently asked questions

How do I know if a gold buyer is giving me a fair price?

Watch what happens at the counter. A fair buyer shows you the market price they are using, weighs your pieces on a scale you can see, tests anything unmarked in front of you, sorts gold by karat, and is happy for you to get a second opinion.

Should I get more than one quote before selling gold in Kelowna?

Yes. A fair figure survives comparison. Kelowna Gold Buyers guarantees to match or beat any quote in Kelowna and the Okanagan Valley, so a second opinion costs you nothing.

Does cleaning or repairing gold raise the offer?

No. Tarnish, dirt and breaks do not change the metal content. A broken chain weighs the same as a fixed one, so money spent on polishing or repairs before selling comes out of your side.

Why does a gold buyer ask for my ID?

Licensed buyers record every purchase against government-issued photo ID, such as a driver's licence or passport. Being asked for it is a sign you are dealing with a licensed buyer.

Is a gold buyer's estimate the same as an appraisal?

No. An estimate is what a buyer will pay you in cash today. A certified appraisal is a formal written valuation, usually at replacement value, prepared by an independent appraiser for insurance, estate or legal purposes.

Want the real number for your own pieces?
A free estimate takes about fifteen minutes and carries no obligation. Call us or read how an estimate works.